Affairs of the Heart?



I was on a train today, coming back into London. I had a perfectly good book with me, but I'd reached a sort of draggy bit and my attention wandered. On the seat next to me was a popular women's magazine 'Red'... this was surely the solution to my crappy attention span! It was also the catalyst for the following rant. I am not a natural ranter. I am generally of a sunny dispostion, but this put the freakers on me BIG STYLE! I also have a Beethoven concerto on in the background and he's crashing around as only the deafest, most disillusioned of composers knows how. This is not helping!

Okay, so I'm not entirely naieve, but this came as a bit of a shock to me. Basically I read an article, the gist of which was this:

'Is it possible/acceptable to use  an affair to stop your marriage/partnership breaking up?'

WHAT!!!!???!!!

Okay, so as an unmarried person, clearly not my area of expertise, but I feel the need to comment all the same...

The article discussed whether you might have grounds to have an extra-marital affair if your marriage is on the rocks, if it kept the marriage going - like life-support. It explained how it's becoming increasingly common, and socially more acceptable for women to have affairs in the name of prolonging a floundering relationship ('for the sake of the children'). It's particularly common in relationships where the sexual element of the relationship has 'burned out'. The theory being that if the woman is being sexually satisfied elsewhere, she'll be happier, and she'll be able to tolerate the crumbling remains of her marriage. What also totally blew my mind was the fact that there are websites with the sole aim of arranging anonymous, private liasons between people seeking affairs. Like a kind of online adultery service. One woman said that some of the men she met through this service were people just like her, married men in realtionships where the physical relationship had disappeared.

What was equally astounding was the concept that an affair could potentially be used to 'mend' a relationship. The idea being that the fallout of the affair could rekindle a couple's passion for each other. I guess that's a little more encouraging than the circumstances described above, as there would have to be some forgiveness there for that one to work. But it's based on the idea that by seeking an affair it would incite sexual jealousy in your partner, so they would become more possessive over you following the threat of the affair to the relationship.

The article got me pretty riled up. Whilst it was a discussion piece, the very fact that it was presented in the way it was, made the concept seem like it was in some way being condoned by the magazine. It sort of suggested that it saw it as an acceptable solution to a problem?!

Most of all it made me sad. It was about something so destructive and hurtful, but it presented it like it was talking about the merits of buying free-range eggs over organic. Like it was some kind of fairly trivial take-it-or-leave-it lifestyle choice. Actually it was describing something fundamentally wrong, and damaging. There was no kind of effort to discuss other ways in which couples have successfully found ways to improve relationships that are breaking down. There was nothing supportive or encouraging. Just an article which spoke to me of the devastating change in the value people place on relationships.

We are a generation watching the wrecking of what right relationship is all about. We have a secret weapon. Not an affair, but God. He is the total Daddy of all relationships - he absolutely loves relationship so much that he put skin on to get close to us. He is also pretty hot at fixing stuff.

I found an amazing CS Lewis quote around the subject. It's kind of wordy and took me a few reads to make sense of. But it's a goodie:

"When I was a youngster, all the progressive people were saying, "Why all this prudery? Let us treat sex just as we treat all our other impulses". I was simple-minded enough to believe that they meant what they said. I have since discovered that they meant exactly the opposite. They meant that sex was to be treated as no other impulse in our nature has ever been treated by civilised people. All the others, we admit, have to be bridled... But every unkindness and breach of faith seems to be condoned provided that the object aimed at is "four bare legs in a bed". It is like having a morality in which stealing fruit is considered wrong - unless you steal nectarines.'

Thus endeth my rant.
hmmm I really don't think that article was written to be relevant to a christian context where hmm there may be a 'simple christian life' of 2 virgins who marry each other and know no other ... hmm the article would just not really be relevant there, bec. if one were as such, one wouldn't know any better

but, hmm in this day and age when the try before you buy culture has led to sex binge culture ... i can see how that sexual heritage can lead to problems when ppl think they want to settle down and marry ... hence, leading to the increasingly popular London thing of the 'open marriage' or 'open relationship'  ... so i'm not sure if 'extra-marital affair' may be the right term for it, bec. an affair seems to apply if the spouse does not know about it ... but yea, I think it seems to be a 'trendy' thing for the up-wardly mobile 'couples' to incorporate several sexual partners even while emotionally they may rely on the one steady ...

... very much like in the Roman or Greek times ... hmm well actually in the Greek times, it was even more twisted with the Men keeping boy 'apprentices' for those purposes hmmm ... am glad that feminism, child protection and condoms has meant we've moved well away from those strange practices!

It's sad but true. My parents do it. I suspect the article didn't touch on what hell it puts the kids through. But perhaps in a strange role of reversal, I suggest that we should be the generation that reverses the trend before it's too late.

Men, pursue the ladies! Ladies, be pursued!
In the words of my rector ' We live in a world that it is post modern and is predominantely pagan'



It's good though that you get upset at what is clearly not right as it easy to be indifferent.


I'm with you Hanski - what???

Why is an affair a more obvious solution that actually working at ones marriage?

Honestly...
I love rants.
I'm with you and caz on this one.

And in case you're wondering, I read Andy Bastable's blog, and was curious enough to follow some of his links
Ranting on clearly rant inducing topics is fine!

I find it as odd as you do - the logic says 'I'm doing a selfless thing, saving my marriage, by indulging an entirely selfish desire'. It also says 'I value monogamy for my kids' stability, but am going to preserve my largely monogomous relationship by having multiple sexual partners' .

And poeple call me irrational for not sleeping around when not married!

Eric Sandras (http://bucknakedfaith.blogspot.com, amazing writer on these kind of issues) came to a church near me and made a reference to a fighter pilot flying an intense test flight, making manoevre after manoevre, trun and stall, climb and descent. She then reached a particular point on the flight instructions telling her to pull up, which she did - only to fly straight into the ground.

This kind of situation demonstrates what so often happens - we think we've got things all worked out, but really we're flying upside down.
Keep ranting! You're speaking a wealth of wisdom.
yo its so out of proportion. on saturday we watched a fish called wanda and i thought how sad it is that you make an apparently jovial film about adultery. not that entertaining really. crumbs
we are doing the pure course at our cu this term and its more and more exciting because God is just so solid, so ordered, so radical, so absolute, and i'm coming to understand that more and more. edinburgh uni did it in the christmas term and got laid into about its stance on homosexuality, so people get a bit jittery when we say we are studying it this term, but its wonderful i think. and God is teaching us all some cool stuff